Renny Harlin's Deep Water delivers exactly what the poster promises, and I mean that as a compliment. A plane goes down in the Pacific. Mako sharks show up. Aaron Eckhart holds it together. If you walk into this movie expecting anything other than that, you walked into the wrong theater.
Eckhart is doing solid, committed work here as the guy who has to keep people alive after the crash. He is not reinventing the wheel, but he is turning it with conviction, and that matters in a movie like this. The man has always been better than the material he gets handed, and Deep Water is no exception. He treats the role with the same seriousness he would bring to a prestige drama, and it elevates everything around him.
The real surprise is the supporting cast. Ben Kingsley plays a karaoke-loving captain on the verge of retirement, which is the kind of detail that makes you wonder who came up with it and then want to buy them a drink. Kingsley commits fully to the bit, and it works. Angus Sampson steals every scene he is in as the passenger who causes the crash. Sampson has been a reliable scene-stealer for years, and this might be the role that gets more people to learn his name.
The crash sequence is genuinely harrowing. Harlin knows how to stage action with clarity, and the impact sequence has a visceral quality that a lot of modern disaster films lose in their pursuit of scale. The shark attacks are bloody and well-staged, delivering exactly the kind of practical, physical tension that made Harlin's best work memorable.
I should be honest about the script. It is not doing any of the heavy lifting here. The dialogue is functional, the character arcs are predictable, and the third act resolves more or less exactly how you think it will. But that is fine. Not every movie needs to be a screenplay showcase. Sometimes what matters is execution, and Harlin executes with the confidence of a man who has been putting people in water with predators since Deep Blue Sea in 1999. The film is sitting at 70% on Rotten Tomatoes, which feels about right.
If you want to appreciate what Harlin does well, watch Deep Blue Sea before this one. That film understood something fundamental about shark movies: they work when the filmmaker commits to the genre without apology. Harlin did it then, and he does it again here. Deep Water is not trying to be more than what it is, and what it is works.
No comments yet